Five Hard-Won Lessons Using Hive

EDIT, 9/8/2016: Hive has come a long way in the two years since I’ve written this. While some of the code snippets might still work, it’s likely the case that this information is so out-of-date to be nothing more than a reflection of working with Hadoop in 2014.

I’ve been spending a ton of time lately on the data engineering side of ‘data science’, so I’ve been writing a lot of Hive queries. Hive is a great tool for querying large amounts of data, without having to know very much about the underpinnings of Hadoop. Unfortunately, there are a lot of things about Hive (version 0.12 and before) that aren’t quite the same as SQL and have caused me a bunch of frustration; here they are, in no particular order.

1. Set Hive Temp directory To Same As Final Output Directory

When doing a “Create Table As” (CTAS) statement in Hive, Hive allocates temp space for the Map and Reduce portions of the job. If you’re not lucky, the temp space for the job will be somewhere different than where your table actually ends up being saved, resulting in TWO I/O operations instead of just one. This can lead to a painful delay in when your Hive job says it is finished vs. when the table becomes available (one time, I saw a 30 hour delay writing 5TB of data).

If your Hive jobs seem to hang after the Job Tracker says they are complete, try this setting at the beginning of your session:

set hive.optimize.insert.dest.volume=true;

2. Column Aliasing In Group By/Order By

Not sure why this isn’t a default, but if you want to be able to reference your column names by position (i.e. group by 1,2) instead of by name (i.e. group by name, age), then run this at the beginning of your session:

set hive.groupby.orderby.position.alias=true;

3. Be Aware Of Predicate Push-Down Rules

In Hive, you can get great performance gains if you A) partition your table by commonly used columns/business concepts (i.e. Day, State, Market, etc.) and B) you use the partitions in a WHERE clause. These are known as partition-based queries. Otherwise, if you don’t use a partition in your WHERE clause, you will get a full table scan.

Unfortunately, when doing an OUTER JOIN, Hive will sometimes ignore the fact that your WHERE clause is on a partition and do a full table scan anyway. In order to get Hive to push your predicate down and avoid a full table scan, put your predicate on the JOIN instead of the WHERE clause:

--#### Assume sales Hive table partitioned by day_id ####--

--Full Table Scan
from employees
left join sales on ( = sales.employee_id)
where day_id between '2014-03-01' and '2014-05-31';

--Partitioned-based query
from employees
left join sales on ( = sales.employee_id and sales.day_id between '2014-03-01' and '2014-05-31');

If you don’t want to think about the different rules, you can generally put your limiting clauses inside your JOIN clause instead of on your WHERE clause. It should just be a matter of preference (until your query performance indicates it isn’t!)

4. Calculate And Append Percentiles Using CROSS JOIN

Suppose you want to calculate the top 10% of your customers by sales. If you try to do the following, Hive will complain about needing a GROUP BY, because percentile_approx() is a summary function:

--Hive expects that you want to calculate your percentiles by account_number and sales
--This code will generate an error about a missing GROUP BY statement
CASE WHEN sales > percentile_approx(sales, .9) THEN 1 ELSE 0 END as top10pct_sales

To get around the the need for a GROUP BY, we can use a CROSS JOIN. A CROSS JOIN is another name for a Cartesian Join, meaning all of the rows from the first table will be joined to ALL of the rows of the second table. Because the subquery only returns one row, the CROSS JOIN provides the desired affect of joining the percentile values back to the original table while keeping the same number of rows from the original table. Generally, you don’t want to do a CROSS JOIN (because relational data generally is joined on a key), but this is a good use case.

5.  Calculating a Histogram

Creating a histogram using Hive should be as simple as calling the histogram_numeric() function. However, the syntax and results of this function are just plain weird. To create a histogram, you can run the following:

histogram_numeric(salary, 20) as salary_hist


The results of this query comes back as a list, which is very un-SQL like! To get the data as a table, we can use LATERAL VIEW and EXPLODE:

   CAST(hist.x as int) as bin_center,
   CAST(hist.y as bigint) as bin_height
FROM (select
      histogram_numeric(salary, 20) as salary_hist
      sample_08) a
LATERAL VIEW explode(salary_hist) exploded_table as hist;

	bin_center	bin_height
0	23507	255
1	31881	340
2	39824	287
3	47615	181
4	55667	164
5	59952	8
6	66034	137
7	75642	82
8	82496	44
9	91431	60
10	100665	21
11	107326	15
12	121248	16
13	142070	2
14	153896	6
15	162310	6
16	169810	2
17	176740	2
18	193925	8
19	206770	2

However, now that we have a table of data, it’s still not clear how to create a histogram, as the center of variable-width bins is what is returned by Hive. The Hive documentation for histogram_numeric() references Gnuplot, Excel, Mathematica and MATLAB, which I can only assume can deal with plotting the centers?  Eventually I’ll figure out how to deal with this using R or Python, but for now, I just use the table as a quick gauge of what the data looks like.

Building JSON in R: Three Methods

When I set out to build RSiteCatalyst, I had a few major goals: learn R, build CRAN-worthy package and learn the Adobe Analytics API. As I reflect back on how the package has evolved over the past two years and what I’ve learned, I think my greatest learning was around how to deal with JSON (and strings in general).  

JSON is ubiquitous as a data-transfer mechanism over the web, and R does a decent job providing the functionality to not only read JSON but also to create JSON. There are at least three methods I know of to build JSON strings, and this post will cover the pros and cons of each method.

Method 1: Building JSON using paste

As a beginning R user, I didn’t have the awareness of how many great user-contributed packages are out there. So throughout the RSiteCatalyst source code you can see gems like:

#"metrics" would be a user input into a function arguments
metrics <- c("a", "b", "c")

#Loop over the metrics list, appending proper curly braces
metrics_conv <- lapply(metrics, function(x) paste('{"id":', '"', x, '"', '}', sep=""))

#Collapse the list into a proper comma separated string
metrics_final <- paste(metrics_conv, collapse=", ")

The code above loops over a character vector (using lapply instead of a for loop like a good R user!), appending curly braces, then flattening the list down to a string. While this code works, it’s a quite brittle way to build JSON. You end up needing to worry about matching quotation marks, remembering if you need curly braces, brackets or singletons…overall, it’s a maintenance nightmare to build strings this way.

Of course, if you have a really simple JSON string you need to build, paste() doesn’t have to be off-limits, but for a majority of the cases I’ve seen, it’s probably not a good idea.

Method 2: Building JSON using sprintf

Somewhere in the middle of building version 1 of RSiteCatalyst, I started learning Python. For those of you who aren’t familiar, Python has a string interpolation operator %, which allows you to do things like the following:

In [1]: print "Here's a string subtitution for my name: %s" %("Randy")

Out[1]: "Here's a string subtitution for my name: Randy"

Thinking that this was the most useful thing I’d ever seen in programming, I naturally searched to see if R had the same functionality. Of course, I quickly learned that all C-based languages have printf/sprintf, and R is no exception. So I started building JSON using sprintf in the following manner:

elements_list = sprintf('{"id":"%s",
                          "top": "%s",
                          "search":{"type":"%s", "keywords":[%s]}
                          }', element, top, startingWith, searchType, searchKW2)

In this example, we’re now passing R objects into the sprintf() function, with %s tokens everywhere we need to substitute text. This is certainly an improvement over paste(), especially given that Adobe provides example JSON via their API explorer. So I copied the example strings, replaced their examples with my tokens and voilà! Better JSON string building.

Method 3: Building JSON using a package (jsonlite, rjson or RJSONIO)

While sprintf() allowed for much easier JSON, there is still a frequent code smell in RSiteCatalyst, as evidenced by the following:

#Converts report_suites to JSON
  report_suites <- toJSON(report_suites)
} else {
  report_suites <- toJSON(list(report_suites))

#API request
json <- postRequest("ReportSuite.GetTrafficVars",paste('{"rsid_list":', report_suites , '}'))

At some point, I realized that using the toJSON() function from rjson would take care of the formatting R objects to strings, yet I didn’t make the leap to understanding that I could build the whole string using R objects translated by toJSON()! So I have more hard-to-maintain code where I’m checking the class/length of objects and formatting them. The efficient way to do this using rjson would be:

#Efficient method
report_suites <- list(rsid_list=c("A", "B", "C"))
request.body <- toJSON(report_suites)

#API request
json <- postRequest("ReportSuite.GetTrafficVars", request.body)

With the code above, we’re building JSON in a very R-looking manner; just R objects and functions, and in return getting the output we want. While it’s slightly less obvious what is being created by request.body, there’s literally zero bracket-matching, quoting issues or anything else to worry about in building our JSON. That’s not to say that there isn’t a learning curve to using a JSON package, but I’d rather figure out whether I need a character vector or list than burn my eyes out looking for mismatched quotes and brackets!

Collaborating Makes You A Better Programmer

Like any pursuit, you can get pretty far on your own through hard work and self-study. However, I wouldn’t be nearly where I am without collaborating with others (especially learning about how to build JSON properly in R!). A majority of the RSiteCatalyst code for the upcoming version 1.4 was re-written by Willem Paling, where he added consistency to keyword arguments, switched to jsonlite for better JSON parsing to Data Frames, and most importantly for the topic of this post, cleaned up the method of building all the required JSON strings!

Edit 5/13: For a more thorough example of building complex JSON using jsonlite, check out this example from the v1.4 branch of RSiteCatalyst. The linked example R code populates the required arguments from this JSON outline provide by Adobe.

Using SQL Workbench with Apache Hive

If you’ve spent any non-trivial amount of time working with Hadoop and Hive at the command line, you’ve likely wished that you could interact with Hadoop like you would any other database. If you’re lucky, your Hadoop administrator has already installed the Apache Hue front-end to your cluster, which allows for interacting with Hadoop via an easy-to-use browser interface. However, if you don’t have Hue, Hive also supports access via JDBC; the downside is, setup is not as easy as including a single JDBC driver.

While there are paid database administration tools such as Aqua Data Studio that support Hive, I’m an open source kind of guy, so this tutorial will show you how to use SQL Workbench to access Hive via JDBC. This tutorial assumes that you are proficient enough to get SQL Workbench installed on whatever computing platform you are using (Windows, OSX, or Linux).

Download Hadoop jars

The hardest part of using Hive via JDBC is getting all of the required jars. At work I am using a MapR distribution of Hadoop, and each Hadoop vendor platform provides drivers for their version of Hadoop. For MapR, all of the required Java .jar files are located at /opt/mapr/hive/hive-0.1X/lib (where X represents the Hive version number you are using).


Download all the .jar files in one shot, just in case you need them in the future

Since it’s not always clear which .jar files are required (especially for other projects/setups you might be doing), I just downloaded the entire set of files and placed them in a directory called hadoop_jars. If you’re not using MapR, you’ll need to find and download your vendor-specific version of the following .jar files:

  • hive-exec.jar
  • hive-jdbc.jar
  • hive-metastore.jar
  • hive-service.jar

Additionally, you will need the following general Hadoop jars (Note: for clarity/long-term applicability of this blog post, I have removed the version number from all of the jars):

  • hive-cli.jar
  • libfb303.jar
  • slf4j-api.jar
  • commons-logging.jar
  • hadoop-common.jar
  • httpcore.jar
  • httpclient.jar

Whew. Once you have the Hive JDBC driver and the 10 other .jar files, we can begin the installation process.

Setting up Hive JDBC driver

Setting up the JDBC driver is simply a matter of providing SQL Workbench with the location of all 11 of the required .jar files. After clicking File -> Manage Drivers, you’ll want to click on the white page icon to create a New Driver. Use the Folder icon to add the .jars:


For the Classname box, if you are using a relatively new version of Hive, you’ll be using Hive2 server. In that case, the Classname for the Hive driver is org.apache.hive.jdbc.HiveDriver (this should pop up on-screen, you just need to select the value). You are not required to put any value for the Sample URL. Hit OK and the driver window will close.

Connection Window

With the Hive driver defined, all that’s left is to define the connection string. Assuming your Hadoop administrator didn’t change the default port from 10000, your connection string should look as follows:


As stated above, I’m assuming you are using Hive2 Server; if so, your connection string will be jdbc:hive2://your-hadoop-cluster-location:10000. After that, type in your Username and Password and you should be all set.

Using Hive with SQL Workbench

Assuming you have achieved success with the instructions above, you’re now ready to use Hive like any other database. You will be able to submit your Hive code via the Query Window, view your schemas/tables (via the ‘Database Explorer’ functionality which opens in a separate tab) and generally use Hive like any other relational database.

Of course, it’s good to remember that Hive isn’t actually a relational database! From my experience, using Hive via SQL Workbench works pretty well, but the underlying processing is still in Hadoop. So you’re not going to get the clean cancelling of queries like you would with an RDBMS , there can be a significant lag to getting answers back (due to the Hive overhead), you can blow up your computer streaming back results larger than available RAM…but it beats working at the command line.

  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.16 Release Notes
  • Using RSiteCatalyst With Microsoft PowerBI Desktop
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.14 Release Notes
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.13 Release Notes
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.12 (and 1.4.11) Release Notes
  • Self-Service Adobe Analytics Data Feeds!
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.10 Release Notes
  • WordPress to Jekyll: A 30x Speedup
  • Bulk Downloading Adobe Analytics Data
  • Adobe Analytics Clickstream Data Feed: Calculations and Outlier Analysis
  • Adobe: Give Credit. You DID NOT Write RSiteCatalyst.
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.8 Release Notes
  • Adobe Analytics Clickstream Data Feed: Loading To Relational Database
  • Calling RSiteCatalyst From Python
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.7 (and 1.4.6.) Release Notes
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.5 Release Notes
  • Getting Started: Adobe Analytics Clickstream Data Feed
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.4 Release Notes
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.3 Release Notes
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.2 Release Notes
  • Destroy Your Data Using Excel With This One Weird Trick!
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4.1 Release Notes
  • Visualizing Website Pathing With Sankey Charts
  • Visualizing Website Structure With Network Graphs
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.4 Release Notes
  • Maybe I Don't Really Know R After All
  • Building JSON in R: Three Methods
  • Real-time Reporting with the Adobe Analytics API
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.3 Release Notes
  • Adobe Analytics Implementation Documentation in 60 Seconds
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.2 Release Notes
  • Clustering Search Keywords Using K-Means Clustering
  • RSiteCatalyst Version 1.1 Release Notes
  • Anomaly Detection Using The Adobe Analytics API
  • (not provided): Using R and the Google Analytics API
  • My Top 20 Least Useful Omniture Reports
  • For Maximum User Understanding, Customize the SiteCatalyst Menu
  • Effect Of Modified Bounce Rate In Google Analytics
  • Adobe Discover 3: First Impressions
  • Using Omniture SiteCatalyst Target Report To Calculate YOY growth
  • ODSC webinar: End-to-End Data Science Without Leaving the GPU
  • PyData NYC 2018: End-to-End Data Science Without Leaving the GPU
  • Data Science Without Leaving the GPU
  • Getting Started With OmniSci, Part 2: Electricity Dataset
  • Getting Started With OmniSci, Part 1: Docker Install and Loading Data
  • Parallelizing Distance Calculations Using A GPU With CUDAnative.jl
  • Building a Data Science Workstation (2017)
  • JuliaCon 2015: Everyday Analytics and Visualization (video)
  • Vega.jl, Rebooted
  • Sessionizing Log Data Using data.table [Follow-up #2]
  • Sessionizing Log Data Using dplyr [Follow-up]
  • Sessionizing Log Data Using SQL
  • Review: Data Science at the Command Line
  • Introducing Twitter.jl
  • Code Refactoring Using Metaprogramming
  • Evaluating BreakoutDetection
  • Creating A Stacked Bar Chart in Seaborn
  • Visualizing Analytics Languages With VennEuler.jl
  • String Interpolation for Fun and Profit
  • Using Julia As A "Glue" Language
  • Five Hard-Won Lessons Using Hive
  • Using SQL Workbench with Apache Hive
  • Getting Started With Hadoop, Final: Analysis Using Hive & Pig
  • Quickly Create Dummy Variables in a Data Frame
  • Using Amazon EC2 with IPython Notebook
  • Adding Line Numbers in IPython/Jupyter Notebooks
  • Fun With Just-In-Time Compiling: Julia, Python, R and pqR
  • Getting Started Using Hadoop, Part 4: Creating Tables With Hive
  • Tabular Data I/O in Julia
  • Hadoop Streaming with Amazon Elastic MapReduce, Python and mrjob
  • A Beginner's Look at Julia
  • Getting Started Using Hadoop, Part 3: Loading Data
  • Innovation Will Never Be At The Push Of A Button
  • Getting Started Using Hadoop, Part 2: Building a Cluster
  • Getting Started Using Hadoop, Part 1: Intro
  • Instructions for Installing & Using R on Amazon EC2
  • Video: SQL Queries in R using sqldf
  • Video: Overlay Histogram in R (Normal, Density, Another Series)
  • Video: R, RStudio, Rcmdr & rattle
  • Getting Started Using R, Part 2: Rcmdr
  • Getting Started Using R, Part 1: RStudio
  • Learning R Has Really Made Me Appreciate SAS